MURDER
CASE #: 1956-1
Margaret Jane Ormesher
Status:
Open
Date of Offense:
Date of Offense:
Offense Location:
Ormskirk, Lancashire
Summary:
Margaret Jane Ormesher, born 1888 in Ormskirk, Lancashire, England, died on 5 May 1956 aged 67–68 from blunt force trauma, with her body discovered on 6 May 1956. She and her sister Mary were bludgeoned to death in the kitchen of their home at Ivy Dene, Asmall Lane, in Ormskirk, Lancashire, England. No arrests were ever made in connection with the murder.
Vital Statistics
Circumstances of Offense:
Mr John Wright, labourer, of 27 Asmall Lane told the inquiry that at 6:45pm he was in the living room of his home and saw Margaret Ormesher entering the garden gate at Ivy Dene. She was wearing a dark grey coat and black hat. On the evening of Saturday, 5 May 1956, Mary walked the 0.7 miles (1.1 km) journey home from the shop alone. She had with her a brown attaché case, which was used to carry the shop takings and contained the whole week's takings of £150. Elderly Mrs Mary Jane Sephton of 56 Halsall Lane witnessed Mary Ormesher pass by from her bedroom window between 10:10 and 10:25pm. Mary was on her own and carrying the attache case in her right hand. Mary arrived home between 10:10pm and 10:25pm. At around 11.15pm and 11.30pm, according to the findings of the inquiry, several neighbours stated that they heard a variety of noises, which included groans, male and female voices, breaking glass and bin lids clattering, all emanating from the sisters' home. Neighbours at nos. 2 and 3 Brickmakers Arms Yard heard these noises but dismissed them at the time as not of a serious nature and went back to bed. At 10:30am on Sunday 6 May 1956, Mrs Whitehouse took a cup of tea to the shop for Mary and found it locked. An hour later, she became concerned and walked to Ivy Dene and knocked on the front door. At around 11:50, Whitehouse sought the help of a Thomas Patrick Cummins who was standing outside his house, 6 Asmall Lane, and they walked round to the back of Ivy Dene. They went into the yard and when Whitehouse saw blood she screamed. The sisters' battered and bloody bodies lay in the kitchen wearing their usual attire, which included cardigans and jumpers. There was evidence that a violent struggle had taken place with serious injuries to the sisters' heads and upper bodies.
Additional Details:
Margaret and Mary were born to Edward and Emma Ormesher and had two other sisters called Ellen and May. Margaret and Mary were unmarried and were both diminutive in stature at less than five feet tall. The sisters were described as 'harmless' and 'helpful' and were well known in the market town. They ran a tobacconists and sweetshop on Church Street, one of the main streets of the town. Mary was known as 'Auntie Polly' to friends and customers. The autopsy was performed by Dr George B. Manning of the Home Office Forensic Science Laboratory, Preston. Manning stated that the sisters' deaths had occurred at around midnight, had been very violent, and that they had been killed with a great deal of force. Witnesses had seen similar pokers and candlesticks in the sisters' house, indicating that they originated there. The investigation into the murder of Mary and Margaret Ormesher was led by Lancashire Constabulary, which launched a large-scale manhunt immediately following the discovery of the bodies on May 6, 1956. Officers flooded the town of Ormskirk, conducting extensive door-to-door canvassing to gather timelines and statements from residents about any unusual noises or sightings on the night of May 5. Police initiated a massive fingerprinting operation targeting every man over the age of 18 in Ormskirk, ultimately collecting over 10,000 samples by September 1956; none matched the print. Over 300 posters were distributed across the region seeking information. The individual, who was believed to be male, was described as being 5ft tall, of medium build with a longish face and high cheekbones. Their face was clean shaven and they had long, dark hair hanging over their forehead. The person was wearing a light-coloured double breasted mackintosh fastened with a belt and grey trousers. The bicycle, which looked fairly new, was a light-blue racing bike with drop handlebars and white mudguards. Police had been aware of a plot to rob the sisters 18 months before the murder but had simply advised them to be careful. One weekend in February 1983 a unidentified individual made a telephone call to a Manchester newspaper and made a claim to know the identity of the murderer. It is believed the call came from a man aged in his 70s who regretted withholding vital facts for many years. The newspaper passed the information to Lancashire CID. The identified murder suspect was investigated but this did not lead to a conviction and police did not provide any further information. The investigation remains open and, as of March 2015, the case remains one of fifteen unsolved murders being investigated by Lancashire Police. The town came to a standstill for the joint funeral of Margaret and Mary. It was a poor day and rained constantly but hundreds of people lined the streets to pay their respects as the funeral cortege passed through the town from the hospital to the Parish Church.
Case Last Updated:
No detective or agency email provided
Can you help?
Without a lead detective or agency contact email, tips to help solve the case can't get to the right place. Community members, you can help by calling the agency and asking for that information to then share with Solve the Case.
Investigating agency
Not listed yet
Ask for the detective handling this case, or an email address where tips can be sent.
Share what you learnTimeline of Events
Neighbors Josephine Whitehouse and Thomas Patrick Cummins discovered the bodies of Margaret and Mary Ormesher in the kitchen at Ivy Dene
Mrs Whitehouse took a cup of tea to the shop for Mary and found it locked
Neighbors began hearing noises from Ivy Dene including groans, voices, breaking glass, and rattling bins, which they dismissed and ignored
Neighbors witnessed Mary walking home carrying the brown attaché case
Mary Ormesher closed her sweet shop and tobacconist's on Church Street and departed alone with the weekly takings of £150 in a brown attaché case
Margaret Ormesher seen entering the garden gate at Ivy Dene by neighbor John Wright
Associated Persons
Emma O. (Mother) - Deceased
Thomas Patrick C. (Neighbor) - Unknown
Edward O. (Father) - Deceased
James B. H. (Witness) - Unknown
Ellen O. (Sibling) - Deceased
Mary Jane S. (Witness) - Unknown
Josephine W. (Neighbor and friend) - Unknown
Norman L. (Cousin and person of interest) - Unknown
Mary O. (Sister) - Deceased
John W. (Witness) - Unknown
May B. (Sibling) - Unknown
Case Content Disclaimer: The details on this case page are sourced from numerous locations to include family, friends, news postings and government public releases. Solve the Case, Inc. does not guarantee the accuracy of any content as case pages are living documents that frequently update as case details expand.

