Solve the Case Logo
No detective or agency contact email provided.Can you help? See how
MURDER
CASE #: 1956-2
MURDER CASE #: 1956-2
Share Case:

Mary Ormesher

Mary Ormesher
Share Case:

Status:

Open

Date of Offense:

Date of Offense:

Offense Location:

Ormskirk, Lancashire

Summary:

Mary Ormesher, born 1889 in Ormskirk, Lancashire, died on 5 May 1956 at age 66–67 from blunt force trauma. She was bludgeoned to death alongside her sister Margaret in their home at Ivy Dene, Asmall Lane, in Ormskirk, Lancashire, England. Despite national media coverage and an extensive investigation in which all adult males were fingerprinted, the identity of the murderer has never been established, and the case remains open with Lancashire Police as of March 2015.

Vital Statistics

Circumstances of Offense:

On the evening of Saturday, 5 May 1956, Mary walked alone from the shop home, carrying a brown attaché case containing the whole week's takings of £150. She was witnessed by Mrs Mary Jane Sephton between 10:10 and 10:25pm, carrying the attaché case in her right hand, and arrived home between 10:10pm and 10:25pm. The walk was dimly lit by gas street lamps and there were no reports of her being followed home. Between 11:15pm and 11:30pm, several neighbours heard groans, male and female voices, breaking glass and bin lids clattering from the sisters' home, but dismissed them as not of a serious nature and went back to bed. The bodies were discovered in the kitchen, both bloodied and battered from a violent attack, lying in pools of blood on the kitchen floor, with the rest of the house appearing otherwise undisturbed. At 10:30am on Sunday 6 May 1956, Mrs Whitehouse brought tea to the shop and found it locked. An hour later, concerned, she walked to Ivy Dene and knocked on the door. Around 11:50, with help from Thomas Patrick Cummins, they went to the back of the house, and when Whitehouse saw blood she screamed. The weapons used were household items: a bent fireplace poker, brass candlesticks, and a broken wine bottle, and both women died from multiple cranial and upper body traumas caused by bludgeoning.

Additional Details:

Mary and her sister Margaret ran a tobacconists and sweetshop on Church Street on one of the main streets of the town, and Mary was known as 'Auntie Polly' to friends and customers. Both sisters were unmarried and diminutive in stature at less than five feet tall. Police initiated a massive fingerprinting operation targeting every man over the age of 18 in Ormskirk, ultimately collecting over 10,000 samples by September 1956; none matched the print. A bloody fingerprint was found on a shard of glass from the broken wine bottle, but no match was found despite the extensive fingerprinting operation. Police also investigated and interviewed World War II evacuees who had previously stayed with the sisters. A key lead emerged from testimony of 11-year-old Barry Houghton, who reported seeing a man in his 30s, approximately 6 feet tall, wearing a trench coat, with dark hair and clean-shaven, riding a blue racing bicycle with white mudguards near the sisters' home at Ivy Dene for three consecutive nights from Wednesday to Friday, May 2 to 4, 1956. By late May, police received daily anonymous letters with potential leads, though most proved unhelpful and yielded no arrests. Local investigations focused on interviews with shop regulars, neighbors, and family members, including the sisters' cousin Norman Light, a local cyclist who was questioned due to his familiarity with the area and mode of transport. One weekend in February 1983, an unidentified individual made a telephone call to a Manchester newspaper and claimed to know the identity of the murderer. The caller was believed to be a man aged in his 70s who regretted withholding vital facts. The newspaper passed the information to Lancashire CID. The identified murder suspect was investigated but this did not lead to a conviction and police did not provide any further information. The Ormskirk Advertiser put up a £50 reward for information leading to the capture of the murderer. Mary had not left a will but the letters of administration granted on June 12 declared an estate of £1722.14s.4d. The sisters lived with a black spaniel dog named 'Trixie' who was known as a reliable alert dog. The dog was in the kitchen where the two ladies were found and had received a considerably heavy blow to the head.

Case Last Updated:

Tasks - Can you help?

ViCAP Entry

Lead Investigator

Family Contact

Share Case:
Mary Ormesher

Tasks - Can you help?

ViCAP Entry

Lead Investigator

Family Contact

Share Case:

No detective or agency email provided

Can you help?

Without a lead detective or agency contact email, tips to help solve the case can't get to the right place. Community members, you can help by calling the agency and asking for that information to then share with Solve the Case.

Investigating agency

Not listed yet

Ask for the detective handling this case, or an email address where tips can be sent.

Share what you learn

Timeline of Events

Sunday, May 6, 1956 11:50am

Neighbor Josephine Whitehouse and local resident Thomas Patrick Cummings entered the Ormesher sisters' home at Ivy Dene on Asmall Lane in Ormskirk and discovered the bodies of Mary and Margaret Ormesher in the kitchen, both bloodied and battered from a violent attack


Sunday, May 6, 1956 10:30am

Mrs Whitehouse took a cup of tea to the shop for Mary and found it locked


Saturday, May 5, 1956 11:15pm

Several neighbours heard groans, male and female voices, breaking glass and bin lids clattering from the sisters' home


Saturday, May 5, 1956 10:10pm

Mrs Mary Jane Sephton witnessed Mary Ormesher pass by from her bedroom window, carrying the attaché case in her right hand


Saturday, May 5, 1956 10:00am

Mary Ormesher closed her sweet shop and tobacconist's on Church Street in Ormskirk around 10:00 p.m., departing alone with an attaché case containing approximately £150 in the week's takings


View Full Timeline

Associated Persons

Edward O. (Father) - Deceased

Margaret O. (Sibling) - Deceased

Josephine W. (Friend) - Deceased

Thomas C. (Neighbor) - Living

Barry H. (Witness) - Living

Norman L. (Person of Interest) - Deceased

Emma O. (Mother) - Deceased

Case Content Disclaimer: The details on this case page are sourced from numerous locations to include family, friends, news postings and government public releases. Solve the Case, Inc. does not guarantee the accuracy of any content as case pages are living documents that frequently update as case details expand.

What would you like to share?

Every case page is free because of supporters like you.

Solve the Case is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit. Your support keeps these cases visible until they are solved.

Make a Donation