MURDER
CASE #: 1969-15
Deborah Lee Shelton
Also Known As:
Debbie
Status:
Open
Date of Offense:
Date of Offense:
Jurisdiction:
Offense Location:
Aptos, California
Summary:
Deborah Lee Shelton, a 12-year-old seventh grader at Aptos Jr. High, was found strangled in a wooded area near a railroad bridge on Aptos Creek Road. Her death remains classified as one of Santa Cruz County's unsolved homicides.
Vital Statistics
Circumstances of Offense:
On January 3, 1969, Deborah left her home in Aptos about 9:30 a.m. to go bike riding. She was last seen alive on Rio Del Mar Boulevard about 11 a.m. that day. According to news accounts from 1969, Deborah's mother Marcia Shelton received a phone call the day of her daughter's disappearance from someone who sounded like a teenager. The caller claimed "they" had her daughter, and the unidentified group would kill Deborah unless Marcia Shelton gave them $500. When her decomposed body was found more than two months later on March 8, 1969, her hands and mouth were bound with duct tape, and it appeared she'd been strangled. Debbie was found lying face-up. Her mouth and neck were covered with her underpants, which were tied "in garrote fashion around [her] neck" and secured with 0.75 inch masking tape. Her bra, t-shirt, and turtleneck sweater were pulled up, exposing her breasts.
Additional Details:
According to Debbie's mother Marcia, Debbie had "had numerous phone conversations with 'Sherman' during the vacation week preceding her disappearance." Neither Sherman nor the caller have ever been identified. According to Terry's account, her grandmother had known a family with a son named Sherman. After Debbie's murder, this Sherman barely left his house for weeks. Terry's grandmother became suspicious of his behavior and confronted his parents, who immediately cut off all contact with her family. The young man eventually joined the military and later took his own life. In 1999 an FBI crime lab determined that the hairs on Debbie's clothing were in fact animal fibers. The case was reopened in 2004, when the Santa Cruz County Sheriff's Office sent DNA evidence to a state crime lab in an effort to find the killer. Despite the intensive investigation, the case quickly grew cold, and there have never been any arrests or official suspects. Marcia Shelton Chauvin, the beautiful Mother of Deborah Lee Shelton, passed away on July 4, 2025.
Case Last Updated:
No detective or agency email provided
Can you help?
Without a lead detective or agency contact email, tips to help solve the case can't get to the right place. Community members, you can help by calling the agency and asking for that information to then share with Solve the Case.
Investigating agency
Ask for the detective handling this case, or an email address where tips can be sent.
Share what you learnTimeline of Events
Deborah buried at Madronia Cemetery in Saratoga
Body identified as Deborah through dental records
Boy discovers Deborah's decomposed body in wooded area near Aptos Creek Road
Mother calls Sheriff's office to report Deborah missing
Ransom call received by Deborah's sister, caller demands $500
Deborah last seen on Rio Del Mar Boulevard
Deborah leaves her home to go bike riding
Associated Persons
Melissa S. (Sibling) - Living
Victoria S. (Sibling) - Living
James Vern S. (Father) - Deceased
Marcia S. (Mother) - Deceased
Sherman U. (Person of Interest) - Unknown
Henry U. (Other) - Living
Loni R. (Friend) - Living
Case Content Disclaimer: The details on this case page are sourced from numerous locations to include family, friends, news postings and government public releases. Solve the Case, Inc. does not guarantee the accuracy of any content as case pages are living documents that frequently update as case details expand.
