SUSPICIOUS DEATH
CASE #: 1986-53
Keith Warren
Status:
Open
Date of Death:
Date of Death:
Jurisdiction:
Death Location:
Silver Spring, Maryland
Summary:
On July 31, 1986, the body of 19-year-old Keith Warren was found hanging from a tree in a wooded area near his home in Silver Spring, Maryland. He was just one month from starting college. The investigation into the 1986 death of 19-year-old Keith Warren has been reopened, with his family having long challenged the initial suicide finding, citing inconsistencies in the case and concerns that he may have been the victim of a lynching.
Vital Statistics
Circumstances of Death:
On Tuesday, July 29th, 1986, Keith received a call from friends and went to hang out with them but never returned home. The next day, July 30th, 1986, his mother, Mary Couey, called the Montgomery County Police to report him missing, but the police informed her that unless he was an invalid or on medication, she would have to wait 48 hours to file a report. July 31st, 1986, at approximately 2:00PM a woman called paramedics at the nearby Fire and Rescue Station to report a suicide. They arrived at Chip Wynn's house, where they found out his girlfriend, Michelle Lawson had called it in. They were directed to the nearby woods, where they found the body of Keith Warren hanging from a tree. The way he had apparently hung himself was practically impossible due to the small tree used and the fact that two ropes were used in the "suicide". Officer Luther Leverette responded to the scene, where his death was almost immediately ruled a suicide. His family was not notified of his death nor was there an autopsy done but instead, his body was automatically sent to a funeral home. In the days preceding his death, several people, including a man named Mark Finley, began searching for him, without explanation. Mark appeared to be especially concerned about finding him. Sherri also remembered that Keith and Mark were not close; in fact, the last time that they had been together, they had gotten into a fight.
Additional Details:
At first, his family accepted the police's ruling that he had committed suicide, but as time progressed, several suspicious occurrences that happened before and after his death made his family suspect that he may have been murdered. A few weeks after the death, Rodney took Mary to the site where Keith had been hung and found that the tree that he was hanging from had been cut down by police; they said that it was "evidence", despite the fact that they had already closed the case. Leaves seen in the photos on the back of his shirt suggested that he had been laid on the ground and then hoisted up into the hanging position. Years of advocacy led to the exhumation of his body in 1994, when a second autopsy reportedly revealed high levels of a chemical associated with antifreeze, raising the possibility that he may have been poisoned prior to being hanged. The surprising results showed that there were several chemicals in deadly amounts in it. It appeared that he had, in fact, been murdered, although some medical examiners claimed that the chemicals were from the embalming process. Mark Finley, who had been searching for him in the weeks before his death, was mentioned in a letter that was with the photographs sent to Mary six years after his death. The letter claimed that "Mark Finley will be next". He soon contacted Mary, claiming that he wanted to visit her, saying that he wanted to "unload". However, one month later, he was found dead, apparently from hitting a curb and being thrown off his bike. Mary, his mother, started The Keith Warren Justice Foundation and continued doing her investigations into her son's death until she passed in 2009. Now, Keith's sister, Sherri Warren, keeps the foundation going. According to Montgomery County Police, "The Montgomery County Department of Police was recently notified by the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner for Maryland of the reclassification of the cause of death for Keith Warren. Pursuant to the Katherine Morris Death Reclassification Act, and following that notification, Montgomery County Department of Police is proceeding forward in compliance with our statutory obligations." The new investigation followed a determination by the Maryland Office of the Chief Medical Examiner that the Medical Examiner's Certificate of Death must be corrected to reflect that the cause and manner of death are undetermined. In 1996, it was featured on *Unsolved Mysteries*, and more recently it was the subject of a three-part Discovery+ docuseries and companion six-part podcast released in 2022, chronicling the Warren family's effort to have the cause of death changed and the investigation reopened.
Case Last Updated:
No detective or agency email provided
Can you help?
Without a lead detective or agency contact email, tips to help solve the case can't get to the right place. Community members, you can help by calling the agency and asking for that information to then share with Solve the Case.
Investigating agency
Ask for the detective handling this case, or an email address where tips can be sent.
Share what you learnTimeline of Events
Investigation into Keith Warren's death was reopened following Maryland Office of the Chief Medical Examiner's reclassification of the cause of death from suicide to undetermined.
Discovery+ released three-part docuseries 'Uprooted' about Keith Warren's death and his sister Sherri's fight for justice.
Keith Warren case featured on Unsolved Mysteries television show.
State's Attorney Doug Gansler reviewed the case; grand jury found insufficient evidence to determine whether death was suicide or homicide.
Keith's body was exhumed and a second autopsy was performed, revealing high levels of toxic chemicals in his system.
On Keith's 25th birthday, an anonymous manila envelope containing official police crime scene photos was left on his mother's doorstep, along with a note stating 'Mark Finley will be next.'
Michelle Lawson called paramedics to report a suicide at Chip Wynn's house. Body of Keith Warren was found hanging from a tree in nearby woods. Officer Luther Leverette ruled it a suicide without conducting an autopsy.
Keith's mother Mary Couey called Montgomery County Police to report him missing; police told her to wait 48 hours.
Keith received a call from friends and went to hang out with them but never returned home.
Associated Persons
Sherri W. (Sibling) - Living
Mary C. (Mother) - Deceased
Rodney K. (Friend) - Living
Mark F. (Person of Interest) - Deceased
Dallas L. (Witness) - Living
Luther L. (Officer) - Living
Michelle L. (Witness) - Living
Case Content Disclaimer: The details on this case page are sourced from numerous locations to include family, friends, news postings and government public releases. Solve the Case, Inc. does not guarantee the accuracy of any content as case pages are living documents that frequently update as case details expand.

